The problem is that some posters set up other accounts as sock puppets for deceitful trolling purposes, acting as if the other accounts are entirely different people who support them.
Spicy and PLA88 have been banned as have many other users who continuously spammed or made personal attacks or baited others. Perhaps you were too busy nitpicking and criticizing to notice this.
We gave all of them the benefit of the doubt and warned them many times, but they simply refused to listen and continued trolling and flame baiting. So they basically asked for a ban in the end.